Fr. Hesse Talk - A Conversation with Fr. Hesse - Part II Dec 20, 2017 20:20:23 GMT
Post by Admin on Dec 20, 2017 20:20:23 GMT
Another gem of Fr. Hesse from the year 2000.
Note that this is the only complete video of this talk on English YouTube channels. This upload provides, fixes audio/video sync problems of other partial uploads of this talk on other channels, and enhances the video by having the audio remastered to remove as much background tape noise as possible.
Notable parts and quotes of Fr. Hesse in this talk:
4:15 - About arguments and who has the truth in arguments.
5:14 - “One of the reasons why I’m not in all too familiar and good terms with the Conciliar Church is because they would want me to quote Vatican II, and after having stopped quoting Vatican II, to quote Paul VI and John Paul II. And they’re highly embarrassed when you come up with quotations that are from the Council of Trent or Pope Pius X that proves them wrong because they’re not interested in the truth; most of the time they defend a certain political purpose or they just want to be right.”
5:58 - “I’ve never been interested in if I [personally] was right [in any given argument/debate]. I’m interested in WHAT is the truth, WHAT is correct, WHAT is right.”
21:39 - “See: this is no way of arguing theology. In theology, you do not: never, ever try to hook somebody else to his own quotation. REAL theology – the way St. Thomas dealt with it – the way most of the greatest theologians did: you only want to find out the truth. You’re not interested in what the other one says.”
25:08 - Fr. Hesse talks about which of the new rites of the sacraments he considers valid.
26:38 - Fr. Hesse talks about what Archbishop Lefebvre said about the validity of the new sacraments.
28:11 - Why he thinks the validity of new rite of Confirmation is doubtful.
37:40 - Fr. Hesse answers the question, “Can a priest or a religious, bishop, archbishop, cardinal, or Pope be a Mason?” Then Fr. Hesse addresses the rumor going around that one of the bishops who consecrated Archbishop Lefebvre as a bishop was a Freemason.
41:37 - Fr. Hesse discusses the Knights of Malta.
43:42 - Fr. Hesse talks about secret societies and about the Opus Dei. “Oh, you want a secret society? Try to find out the membership of all the members in the Opus Dei… And you got a secret society! Try it. ‘The Escriva testimonies’… Excuse me: ‘the Escriva Witnesses’… language mistake, beg your pardon. The Jehovah Witnesses, the Escriva Witnesses… Try to find out a full membership list of ‘the Escriva Witnesses’ […]”
44:35 - Interviewer: “Evidently the Opus Dei: you think there’s something subversive with them?” Fr. Hesse: “Yes, definitely!”
46:24 - “By the way, the founder of the Opus Dei said that he had a doctorate not only in theology but also in canon law. I’ve never found anybody who would show me that. People have asked the Opus Dei to produce the document. And there’s no answer. I’m not saying he’s a liar. I’m just saying: I would like to see it.”
48:25 - Fr. Hesse discusses how Pope John Paul II kissing the Quran was a public act of apostasy (but it's not considered a formal act of apostasy).
1:00:58 - Fr. Hesse answers whether beatifications and canonizations are infallible, but he says “he is open to facts” and open to reconsider things more deeply.
1:03:47 - On the indefectibility of the Church.
1:09:03 - About how the future Pope John XXIII sided with the local Communist union against the Italian state.
1:11:09 - Fr. Hesse talks about how Pope John XXIII lied.
1:13:37 - Interviewer: “The American Church is trying to tell everyone that Vatican II was a godsend to the Church.” Fr. Hesse: “Maybe as a punishment.”
1:14:37 - “Infallibility is THE fashionable error of the century.” (That is, ignorance of the conditions of and an incorrect application of the dogma of infallibility is the error of the century).
1:17:30 - “So the German bishops got together (in those days they were Catholic)…”