Proving the Impossibilty of Theistic Evolution - Paula Haigh

. . .based on the conviction that "Theistic Evolution" is heresy, debilitating the Church today and causing more harm ultimately than atheistic evolution because of its reduction of God to a mechanism for the supposed natural processes of evolution, its lack of reverence for Holy Scripture as the revealing Word of God, and its insidious attack upon Catholic doctrine and tradition. - December 1976



Dedicated to Mary Immaculate,
the Woman of Genesis 3:15
Who Crushes the Serpent's Head
and Destroys All Heresies
Throughout the World.

I cannot stress enough...the absolute necessity for a Catholic to understand, to know, what is meant by CATHOLIC FAITH. In order to have
a deep love for this priceless possession, a Catholic must know what it is, and how it is different from any other Faith. We...read the warning of
Pope St. Pius X: that the axe is being laid at the very root, that is to the Faith itself... (from F. Albers, The Hidden Schism, p.5, International
Catholic Priests' Assoc., St. George's, Polegate, E. Sussex, BN26 5DG England)

Now therefore fear the Lord, and serve Him in sincerity and in truth; put away the gods which your father served on the other side of the river
and in Egypt, and serve the Lord. And if you are unwilling to serve the Lord, choose this day whom you will serve, whether the gods which
your fathers served on the other side of the River, or the gods of the Amorites in whose land you dwell. But as for me and my house, we will
serve the Lord. (Joshua 24:14:15)

Introduction

The following theses are offered as an outline of one possible way to construct a defense of Creation against the error of evolution. A book
could be written on each single thesis, developing the theology, supporting it with quotations and examples from Holy Scripture, from the
Fathers and Doctors of the Church, from empirical science, analyzing the pro's and con's of the question from traditional and modem sources.
And this is work which needs to he done.

Perhaps students will see in the material indicated here the almost infinite possibilities for elaboration, for analysis and for synthesis. And perhaps
some will be inspired to commence research in this field and come to realize, as l have, that here, indeed, is the most exciting and vitally
important area of study confronting us today. It is a new frontier, for the old materialism causes nothing but unhappiness and tragic waste of
talent and of life, as modern thought becomes more and more confused, turning in upon itself only to find either the emptiness and disillusion of
the cultic counterfeits or the "No exit" of a Sartrean hell.

Creation theology and Creation science offer the one true solution for our age, obsessed as it is with the mysteries of the cosmos, with the
vastness of the universe, and with the history of earth and Iife. Here is the possibility of a real breakthrough and with it, a return to sanity for the
academic disciplines and a return home for the cheated and dispossessed of the world.

The humanists tell us that "No deity will save us; we must save ourselves." This is spiritual and intellectual suicide for modern man. Belief in
evolution leads to the death wish and self-destruction. Man is a creature and can only destroy himself by denying his creature-hood and his
Creator. Christians who realize this and who love mankind, even as Our Divine Lord did when He died on the Cross to save us all and to
manifest His love, will not he able to confront this modern humanistic attitude of God-rejection with anything but grief. Only those nominal
Christians who are themselves infected with this deadly poison of unbelief are able to view the modern scene with complacency.

Some think to save modern man by concurring with his evolutionary "faith" and injecting God into this false system. But this does not work, for
evolution rejects God as surely as Creation rejects evolution. The Humanist Manifesto states:

“Religious humanists regard the universe as self-existing and not created. Science affirms that the human species is an emergence from natural
evolutionary forces. As far as we know, the total personality is a function of the biological organism transacting in a social and cultural context.
There is no credible evidence that life survives the death of the body. We continue to exist in our progeny and in the way that our lives have
influenced others in our culture”.

It goes on to assert that "traditional religions" are obstacles to human progress. This is nothing but the mind of Satan proposing again and again
to man, the original temptation to the original sin of rejecting God in favor of self. Christians must realize that the evolutionary system is per se,
of its very nature, God-rejecting. Its raison d'etre is to be rid of God, our Creator. What folly, then, to hope to redeem it by making God its
cause and planner. You will just as soon redeem Satan himself.

Therefore, the purpose of our theses is two-fold: 1) to demonstrate that the theory of evolution is incompatible with the doctrines of Catholic
Faith and 2) to defend those doctrines of the Faith that evolution most directly attacks.

There is no doubt in my mind that eventually the Church will be forced to condemn evolutionary theology, also called process theology, as the
dangerous novelty that it is. Pope Saint Pius X singled out evolution as the principal doctrine of the Modernists in his encyclical, Pascendi
(1907, #26, D 2094). And in 1950 Pope Pius XII condemned polygenism as absolutely against Faith (#37, D 2328). Catholic theologians and
scientists, however, were not deterred by these warnings, and so, as Solange Hertz said, "We cannot wait for formal condemnations before
side-stepping heresy. When these are made the disease is already admittedly out of control, and we may be stricken."¹

We cannot go wrong if we follow the "Rules of Faith" laid down by Saint Vincent of Lerins (d.445) in his famous Commonitory or "Reminder":

A fourth note could be added under the name of novelty as a sure sign of heresy or at least suspicion of heresy, for St. Vincent speaks
frequently of "novel misbelief, "novel doctrines" and "the garbage of heretical novelty," quoting Saint Paul: "Though we or an angel from heaven
preach any other gospel unto you than that which we have preached unto you, let him be accursed.(Gal 1:8) We rely not upon our own ability
but upon "the authority of the Divine Law [Holy Scripture] and by appeal to the Church's determinations." (Chapter X, 27)

Such is our attitude towards evolution in the absence as yet of any formal determination and definite condemnation of this so-called scientific
theory which has spawned a false theology and philosophy and leads, in turn, to many scandalous and heretical practices.

What is threatened today is the continuity of all true doctrine, even its very survival in any kind of socially visible form of witness. And this is
particularly true of the doctrine of Creation which is so fundamental to the central doctrines of Original Sin, the Incarnation and Redemption.
People who think that submission of the human mind to Divine Truth as revealed in Holy Scripture and in the teaching of the Church is
submission to repression and boredom or an obstacle to true progress, only reveal their own prejudices and superficiality. It is the
contemporary dominance, even tyranny, of positivist science, of God-less and skeptical empiricism, it is the willful exclusion of theology and
metaphysics from their proper place in the hierarchy of the sciences and it is the rejection of the unity of the sciences including theology and
metaphysics and according them their proper place that has brought about our contemporary impoverishment in knowledge. This reduction of
all things to the physical threatens more and more to result in a fatal confusion of priorities and rejection of saving truth on the part of too many
people within the Church. One example of this fatal confusion is the exaltation of physical needs before spiritual needs.

Today, in practice if not in theory, it seems much more important to ensure three meals a day, proper housing, clothing and a high standard of
living than to dispel the double darkness of sin and ignorance by a strong and steady proclamation of the Truth without which there can be no
true or lasting love. Thus we witness an unprecedented neglect of Catholic doctrine. The Church exists for no other purpose than the
preserving, transmission and nourishing of the Truths of divine Faith. All else must flow from this, as all the other Commandments flow from the
First. The reduction of all doctrine and all moral precept to the second great commandment, to love one's neighbor, and the reduction of the
First Commandment itself to the Golden Rule is nothing less than the triumph of secular humanism in the Church and a betrayal of the Church's
mission.

Furthermore, with respect to Holy Scripture, the constant teaching of the Church upholds the view that the Bible is Divine Rhetoric and teaches
scientific and historical as well as religious truth in the mode of discourse of this Divine Rhetoric. To allow Holy Scripture to be sliced up,
fragmented into religious truth and some other kind of non-inspired error is to return to the Reformation and to sanction private interpretation
where before it was condemned. For who is to determine what is religious truth in Holy Scripture and what is non-religious and therefore not
important or not relevant truth or error but only Scripture interpreted by Tradition and the Magisterium?

And so these theses are submitted to the judgment of Holy Mother Church even while this judgment is happily anticipated. And I submit with
the earnest prayer that some word of encouragernent will be given so that this portion of Catholic Truth may once again become a living and
enlivening influence in the Church and in the world where it is so desperately needed to meet and offset the Satanic doctrine of evolution that
would obscure in our minds the knowledge of our Creator, and root out of our hearts the love we owe to our Father, Redeemer and Sanctifier.


1. The Three Divine Persons are one single, common Principle of the Creation.

2. God alone created the world.

3. To create means to produce from nothing.

4. The world had a beginning in time.

5. All that exists outside of God was, in its whole substance, created out of nothing, in the beginning, by God, the Blessed Trinity.

6. God has created a good world.

7. No creature can as principal or secondary-instrumental cause, from or by its own power, create anything from nothing or bring new beings
into existence that transcend their own nature.

8. The action of God termed Divine Preservation or Conservation is not a communicable attribute but is proper to God alone because it
involves the continual pouring out of existence of which God alone is the Author and Source.

9. The Action of God termed Divine Concursus, by which God cooperates immediately with all secondary causes, can in no way be invoked as
an agent or mechanism for evolutionary ascent from kind to kind or from species to species.

10. The Action of God is without either motion or time, without effort or work.

11. The Gift of Divine Grace in the human soul and the elevation of man to the supernatural order by Divine Grace is not a fit analogy or any
kind of analogical basis for arguing in favor of evolutionary transformation from lower kinds to higher by means of a self-transcendence granted
by God in the natural order analogous to that in the supernatural order.

12. The Thomistic relation of creation gives no support to a theory of continuous creation.

13. Creation is not a miracle but rather the very initiation and constitution of the natural and supernatural orders which miraculous as well as all
non-miraculous processes presuppose.

14. All things were created to glorify God.

15. The Hexaemeron (Six Days of Creation Week) plus other affirmations of Holy Scripture, such as the 10-fold repetition of according to its
kind, constitute positive guiding principles for all scientists.

16. The first man, Adam, was created directly by God from the dust of the earth and his body as well as his soul were created immediately by
God on the Sixth day of Creation Week.

17. The first woman, Eve, was, in the words of Genesis 2:21-22, made from the side of Adam while he slept.

18. The whole human race stems from one single pair, Adam and Eve.

19. Man, as human nature, consists of two essential parts, a material body and a spiritual, immortal soul of which he is one composite being,
unified by the substantial form of the rational soul.

20. The rational-intellectual soul of man is per se, of and by itself, as formal cause, the essential substantial form of the human composite, that
which causes it to be human. Without the rational soul which is a simple, immaterial, spiritual, intellectual and immortal principle, there is no
human being.

21. Every human being possesses an individual immortal soul.

22. Every individual soul is immediately and directly created by God out of nothing at the moment of conception.

23. Adam and Eve were endowed by God with supernatural life in the form of sanctifying grace and with other certain preternatural gifts,
namely, bodily immortality, perfect control of nature by reason of freedom from irregular desire, i.e., concupiscence, freedom from suffering and
a knowledge of natural and supernatural truths infused by God. Adam and Eve received these gifts not only for themselves but for their
posterity.

24. Our first parents in Paradise sinned grievously through transgression of the Divine probationary command.

25. As a consequence of the grievous original, personal sin of pride leading to disobedience, our First Parents
1) lost sanctifying grace
2)provoked the anger and indignation of God, and 3) became subject to death and the dominion of the Devil.

26. Adam's original personal sin is transmitted to his posterity, not by imitation or by being born into the human condition, but by natural
generation of biological descent and is inherited by us along with our human nature which, by reason of this sin, finds itself in a state of
deprivation that can only be remedied by the application of the merits of the Passion and Death of Our Lord Jesus Christ in Baptism and other
Sacraments of the Church.

27. In the beginning of time, God created spiritual beings, Angels, out of nothing.

28. The Bible is both inspired and inerrant in all that it asserts, enunciates, and suggests because God is the principal Author thereof.

29. The Deluge described in Genesis 6-8 was a Flood that covered the entire globe, that is, it was universal both anthropologically and
geographically, and the fossil record of the geologists is a Monument-Memorial-Reminder for modern man of this watery catastrophe sent upon
the earth as a punishment for sin.

30. The theory of evolution undermines divine Catholic Faith, poisons the mind in which it takes residence, obscures the supernatural truths of
Faith and warps the natural powers of reason. It is incompatible with divine Catholic Faith and in its theistic form, constitutes a major heresy
infecting the Church today.

Full article elaborating these theses by P. Haigh here: www.catholicapologetics.info/modernproblems/evolution/etheistic.htm